
It was bad, before, when it was Casey, when she thought her sister was being tortured, when that thing that had been inside her tricked her and killed those paramedics and did who knows what else while on the run. Her father's accident, her car crash — it turned their whole family upside goddamn down, and for this. This was always the endgame, to get back the girl who got away, a decades' old grudge that the rest of them are just collateral damage in. And for all that Kat is scared, more so than she can remember having been in her entire life, even more so than when she came to in a car smashed against a telephone pole and found Julia's lifeless eyes staring back at her, she's pissed, too. All of their lives have been decimated, Casey more traumatized than she knows she'll ever really comprehend, their father still recovering, her career ruined, Julia dead.
Her mother gone, apparently. This is integration. It's permanent, the demon said, as difficult as it is to process that when the person standing in front of them, keeping them all here, looks and sounds exactly the same. At least with Casey, when they finally found her again, she'd been all but unrecognizable, the voice coming out of her nearly inhuman. As disturbing as that had been, to say the least, it had been easy to separate that from her sister. Easier than this, at least, all of them being terrorized by a woman who bears a perfect resemblance to Angela Rance, except for a demeanor that isn't hers at all, that sends a shiver running down Kat's spine.
"I'm going to kill you," her father says, unflinching, and Kat doesn't think she's ever loved him so much. Just a few weeks ago, he probably wouldn't have even been able to string that sentence together. Now, he doesn't even seem to hesitate.
"Now, that's the kind of talk that we just can't afford," the demon replies, her mother's voice lilting.
Emboldened, Kat doesn't wait a moment before chiming in. "Marcus is gonna find you," she says, miraculously keeping her voice steady, seemingly unfazed. She believes it, though. Father Marcus saved Casey; whatever her previous misgivings about him, she thinks now that he might be the one person equipped to do something about this.
"Well, then, I'll kill him, too." The demon sounds almost cheerful. It only spurs her on.
"Really?" she asks, brow arching slightly, eyes steely. "The way I heard it, you got your ass handed to you by a twelve-year-old girl. What kind of all-powerful demon lets himself get chucked out a window?"
She's walking a dangerous line and she knows it. She also doesn't care. This can't get any more fucked up than it already is, not really, and she isn't just going to sit back and take this. She's done enough of that already.
The demon swings a hand towards her, and Kat knows what's about to happen, braces herself for the impact, only — it doesn't come. Her mother's palm hovers inches from her cheek instead, and for as confused as she knows she looks, the demon wearing her mother's face only looks more so. Seconds pass, hanging heavy in the air, and then realization seems to dawn on it:
"Regan."
All that talk of integration, permanence — maybe it's not so permanent after all. Maybe her mother really is still in there somewhere. Maybe there's hope. Kat isn't much for praying, except for show, to appease her family, but she's almost tempted to now. If nothing else, it would be a nice way of metaphorically spitting in this asshole's face. Casey didn't go down without a fight. Her mother didn't go down without a fight, all those years ago. She doesn't intend to, either, her back rigid and expression schooled as she waits to see what comes next, hoping in the back of her head for Father Tomas to wake up or for Father Marcus to barge in.
Neither happens. Instead, the demon, all too pleased with itself, says, "We're going to play a game. A game that can end at any time. And all you have to do, Regan—" It sets a hammer down on the coffee table with a dull thud, and Kat feels her stomach drop a little, all too sure of where this is going. "Is open the damn door."
Her eyes widen, and she takes a breath, glancing from her father to Casey, before the demon says, "Round and round we go," and gives the hammer a spin.
"Oh, my God," Casey breathes, her eyes brimming with tears. Kat isn't sure she looks much better herself, expression faltering, but for her sister's sake, for the sake of not letting this thing win, she's determined not to let herself crack.
Not even when the hammer slows to a stop, pointing directly at her.
"Looks like we have a winner!" the demon says. "The birdie with the broken wing." Kat's face does crumple then, her composure slipping. It's taken so much already, and now it's just going to take more.
"Casey, dear," it continues, "I want you to pick up that hammer." Casey, still in her seat, is pulled to her feet by the demon. As if it hasn't done enough to her already. "Let's go. Come on. There we go. Good." Casey's breath catches. "It's okay, baby. Yeah. Pick it up."
Casey does, still moving slowly, reluctantly, looking on the verge of falling apart.
"Good. There you go. Now come on over here."
Kat watches as the demon guides Casey over towards her, all but holding her breath, waiting for whatever comes next. "And what I want you to do with that hammer is to hit your sister just as hard as you can." She's barely keeping it together now and she knows it, and she isn't sure if it's better or worse when the next instruction is, "Start with the knee."
"Don't," her father, silent for so long, interrupts. "Don't do it. We're not gonna play your sick little games."
They already are, though, and they have been for such a long time, and Kat, already bracing herself for what comes next, doesn't see a way out of this one. The demon has the upper hand. It has for longer than any of them realized, and maybe they won't give in easily, but there's only so much they can do.
"I'm gonna give you until the count of ten to do it," the demon says, still too cheerful, taking far too much pleasure out of all of this. "Otherwise, I'm gonna tear both of Daddy dearest's arms off."
As if on cue, her father's arms stretch unnaturally out to the side, his face contorting with pain. For a moment, Kat feels like she might be sick, distantly aware of Casey yelling, "No!"
There's only one way this ends. She won't let it go any other way.
"One."
Her lip quivers, her gaze stuck on her father, crying out where he's become some human game of tug-of-war on the couch.
"Two."
"Please, you don't have to do this, please," Casey begs, the words spilling out rapid-fire, as if pleading will make any difference.
"Three."
"Please, no, please!"
Between Casey's begging and her father's yelling, Kat feels herself break, a sob in her throat, shoulders shaking.
"Listen to me," their father says, speaking quickly in turn, like he doesn't think he has much time left. "I love you both so much."
"Four."
"Please, please, don't do this," Casey continues, the hammer hanging heavy at her side.
"Okay, this is not—" Their father manages to say through clenched teeth, fervent, staring down Casey. "This is not your fault. Do you hear me?" Kat wants to say the same thing — tried to, a night ago, only that was when the people hurt were strangers, not their own family.
"No!"
"Five."
"Daddy, no." Casey's voice is softer this time, almost resigned.
"Every day I wake up, I'm so proud. I'm so proud to be your dad."
"Six."
"Please, please, no, please!"
Finally, Kat finds her voice. She won't let this happen. If their father dies, it won't be Casey's fault, won't be any of theirs but the sick fuck running this show, but there's an easy fix here, and she might as well take it. She was probably never going to dance again anyway. The knowledge of that doesn't stop her stomach from turning or keep her voice from breaking, but it's the only small comfort she's got. "Do it, Case."
"Seven."
"And your mom — your mom loved you too."
"No, please," Casey says, her voice small and broken in a way that only makes Kat more determined.
"You can't ever forget — You can't ever forget that."
He's preparing for the end, Kat thinks, and is probably close to it, too. Casey, still, is unmoving. Kat can't blame her, given the decision at hand and the cruelty of her having to be the one to do this, but they're running out of time.
"Eight."
"Do it!" Kat shouts, desperate now, unwilling to accept any other outcome here.
"I can't," Casey whimpers, and as close as they are, Kat knows that pleading won't work with her any more than Casey's pleading had worked with the demon. There's only one thing to do. Casey already has so much on her shoulders, bearing so much more guilt than she should have to. The way she'd looked reading about the paramedics who'd died filters through Kat's mind, makes her steel herself. She won't give her little sister one more burden. She won't let their father die when the alternative, at least, won't put anyone else in the ground.
"Nine."
She snatches the hammer out of Casey's hand, and before she can stop to think about it, before she can even brace herself for the impact, she brings it down hard on her kneecap, crying out as Casey shrieks. It's a sick, unnatural sight, and she screams again, pain radiating through her whole leg, but then her father slumps down, and though she's crying now, unable to hold it back anymore or catch her breath, it's the only thing she could have done. Even the accident — the one that wasn't really an accident — didn't hurt this much. It makes sense. The damage wasn't so severe. Her knee was busted, but it wasn't in pieces. She can barely look at it now, as if doing so somehow makes it worse; she shuts her eyes instead, doubled over and gasping for breaths between sobs.
It's because of that, she thinks, that it takes her a moment to notice the absence of any other sound in the room. Casey isn't crying anymore, her father isn't shouting, that fucking demon isn't laughing her mother's laugh. She's in a living room, but it isn't her living room, and she's alone. Wincing, trying uselessly to hold back more tears, she wonders if this is some trick, some mind game, but she can't imagine that that would be so easy or so quiet, not after the torture they've all just been put through. Maybe she's passed out, but she doesn't think she would be in so much pain otherwise, shaking slightly on a couch she's never seen before.
As little sense as it makes — and then, has anything about any of their lives made any kind of sense lately? — Kat does the only thing she can think to, hands hovering over her shattered kneecap like she wants to cradle it but is afraid to touch it. She calls, her voice weaker than she'd like to admit, "Hello?"